Dual-employed partners often need to compare their insurance benefits to select the plan or combination of plans that will best fit their needs and financial goals.
My new job pays 100% of individual premiums and 50% of dependent premiums. The partner’s job pays 30%. This comparison shows that the high percentage paid does not always mean a better deal, at least in terms of our desired PPO plan.
When comparing plans offered by your respective empolyers, follow two simple steps:
Step One: Find out if either employer will provide a cash payout if you do not use their medical benefits. Some companies will pay you in salary what you are not using in medical benefits.
For my company, however, this was not an option.
Step Two: Compare the fees associated with each plan and decide on a plan of action. Be sure to consider premiums, deductible, co-pays, percentage paid, etc. (See final remarks for additional considerations.)
Luckily for us, the plans at both HIS and HER companies were simmilar and required only a comparison of employee-paid premiums. Here are the comparisons that I went through:

Cost Comparison: This table lists the costs of each plan based on HIS and HER company; these are the fees that we pay and do not include employer contributions. HER company does not have a plan similar to the POS plan we currently participate in.

Options: The second chart details the comparisons I used in order to determine our plan of action.
- Plan 1: No Change. We stay with the family plan at HIS company that we have now.
- Plan 2: We switch to the family plan at HER company.
- Plan 3: We change to the Individual+Child plan at HIS company and sign up for the individual plan at HER company.
- Plan 4: We change to the Individual plan at HIS company and sign up for the Individual+Child at HER company.
Plan of Action: As you can see, the best option for us is Plan 3 - change to Individual+Child plan at HIS company and enroll in the individual plan at HER company.
Savings: Our annual savings will be $1,288.82 a year, $107.40 a month, and $49.57 a paycheck.
Final Thoughts: If you compare your health plans and discover that they are both fairly similar in all aspects, including employee-paid premiums, pay attention to the full premium. If you ever lose your job and must rely on COBRA, this is the monthly fee that you will be required to pay. For dual-earner families, this may not be a big consideration because you can always begin using the insurance benefits from the employed partner.
Also, the type of coverage desired obviously has a big impact on the fees. I personally desire PPO plans for my own, personal medical care. For the rest of my family, the POS plan that we currently have is sufficient. Our plan of action will meet the needs of our family and our situation well.