Avoiding the “I” in Joint Finances

The newest bump in our joined finances adventure appears to be an “our” framework retrofitted onto a “your” outlook. Yes, we now have a joint account and our income is being pooled together – but the partner has taken the viewpoint that it is all my money now and no longer his. This has stirred up some frustrations when talking about the household budget, personal spending, and current savings.

Background: I am very budget focused and highly active in watching my finances and making sure that I stay within the lines. I am adamant that we must have a household budget in order to reach our financial goals. The partner thinks that budget is a dirty word and takes a more hands off approach. September was the first month where we joined finances and started using a new budgeting program – one that will meet each of individual preferences for spending but is seen as something I am pushing by the partner and as a compromise by myself.

Problem: Earlier this year, before becoming a legal ‘we’ and formally living together, we each contributed $5,000 toward a home purchase that fell through. $5,000 of that, which I’ve viewed as “mine”, was put into our joint savings account. I’ve been actively asking about the other $5,000 that was still in the partner’s personal accounts and making the partner uncomfortable. The partner didn’t like that I wanted the last of his money. I was getting frustrated that my portion was put into our account while he was keeping his portion. The partner revealed that he sees our joint accounts as mine and that that money was the only thing that was still his.

I/we: Through many conversations over the weekend, we realized that we did not have the same feelings toward our joint finances. Because I have spearheaded the recent move to the implementation of a new budgeting program, the partner sees me as the owner of the household finances. Also, the new accounts that we’ve joined and established are not accounts that the partner is used to using and he feels that he doesn’t have access and that they are really just my accounts with our name on them. I have added to this feeling of separation from the household budgeting by saying “I will put $$ into your personal account” instead of “we can put $$ into your personal account.”

Solutions: So, to help reduce the “I/you” outlook and move to the needed “our”, I will be making a strong effort to watch how I phrase things. Also, the budgeting program is going to be placed on the partner’s desktop instead of my laptop. Additionally, the joint checkbook and bills will remain accessible to both of us and I will make sure the partner knows how to use the budget program to manage bills. Finally, the $5,000 that is in our joint account will go back into my personal account. This returns the piece of mind that I will have some individual savings (I took my savings to $0 for the house and wedding) and will remove my need to see where that $5,000 of his is at. This will drop our joint savings considerably and will basically leave us starting from scratch. However, if we need additional money later, we can both decide what to contribute from our individual funds. I think this is the best approach for the savings situation as it allows us both to retain some ownership of our pre-partnered life.

Conclusion: The heated dialogues we were having this month traced back to feelings or impressions unequal access and ownership of finances. I feel that all couples should have equal understanding and feelings of responsibility for household money. If one person does the larger share of the financial work, it is very important to make sure the other one is informed on how to do the work. Ideally, sharing the financial responsibility equally will help keep both partners informed of current fiscal status and make sure both partners know what is happening and how to manage the finances fully if needed.

6 Responses to “Avoiding the “I” in Joint Finances



  • Tiredbuthappy
    October 16th, 2006 13:53
    1

    Thanks for this post. It sounds like you’re making progress.

    We combined finances in a similar, limited way. We each still have personal accounts that don’t get added to very much, and most of our ongoing income and savings goes into joint ventures.

    When we bought our house, instead of each of us putting all our savings into it, we each put in the same percentage of our total savings. I put up more because I had more money to begin with.


  • 3 Things About Money
    October 17th, 2006 11:14
    2

    Thanks for this post…we are still having issues moving into an “our” approach, primarily because of our very differing views on spending (I’m the budget babe) so we split everything 50/50 on joint expenses. I’d like to move beyond that, but well, it keeps the resentment down. It’s an ongoing conversation. Anyway, thanks.


  • Year in Review: Anniversary No. 1 » The Weight of Money
    April 6th, 2007 10:36
    3

    […] The partner and I combined finances in October 2006 and discovered that there is no room for “I” in joint finances. […]


  • Which Should You Choose: Joint or Separate Finances? ∞ Get Rich Slowly
    April 25th, 2007 08:01
    4

    […] The Weight of Money: Avoiding the ‘I’ in joint finances — This is a great real-life example of the issues involved with merging finances. […]


  • Should Married Couples Combine Finances? | Bride Diva
    October 30th, 2007 11:13
    5

    […] The Weight Of Money- Discusses some issues that can arise from trying to combine finances. […]


  • Cat
    November 5th, 2007 18:24
    6

    I have really enjoyed this post so even though you posted well over a month ago, I’ll still comment. My boyfriend and I live together and we plan to marry within the next five years. We have established a joint household account and each have our own separate accounts (I have four, he has three). Since I love thinking about and researching budgeting, investing and personal finance I’m assumed the postion of chief household budgeter but already I can see myself doing things like saying “I’l transfer x” not “we can transfer x” and not helping him to understand and get used to the banking process at our joint account (where I have my two main personal accounts). So your post has been very eye-opening for me and I really appreciate it!

Leave a Reply